see the project report here
Transkript
see the project report here
CONVENTION ON WETLANDS (Ramsar, Iran, 1971) Rue Mauverney 28, CH-1196 Gland, Switzerland Tel. +41-22-999-0170, Fax +41-22-999-0169 E-mail: ramsar@ramsar.org, Web: http://ramsar.org/ Wetlands for the Future Fund (WFF) Section E Standard format for the preparation of Final Reports (To be filled in by the implementing agency/organization/proponent) Country: Turkey Title of the Project: Effective Management of Ramsar Sites in Turkey Project code: 7501-400/SGF/08/TU Year of approval: 2008 Project Officer (see Section 5 below for further details): Can Yeniyurt Date project was completed: March 2010 Date final report provided: August 2010 Have you provided the Final Report in electronic as well as hard copy format? Have you enclosed? a) Some suitable photographs or color slides (with the necessary description) illustrating the project? Yes b) the copies of the materials produced with WFF funding (if applicable)? No 1. Abstract The project started to be implemented by April 2009. The initial action undertaken for the project was to explore the existing wetland management structures in Turkey. Meetings were held with NGOs and Government institutions to generate ideas for the best wetland management structure based in the previous experiences in Turkey. Following the outputs of these meetings were discussed with the Ministry of Environment and Forestry but also with the key decisionmakers and diverse stakeholders in the Kızılırmak Delta. As a result, all parties agreed that it would be beneficial to identify a different additional management structure than the Local Wetland Commission. The responsibility of the Local Wetlands Commission covers all the wetlands within a province and only includes members at provincial level but the setting up of technical commission for a specific area including members from land users such as farmer etc. will support the successful implementation of the wetland management plan. Successively, we directed our activities to support the establishment of a Technical Commission for the Kızılırmak Delta by the Local Wetlands Commission. Our first activity with the Kızılırmak Delta Technical Commission was to organise a field visit to the Gediz Delta. The aim of the visit was to create a ground for experience sharing between the two deltas. The technical commission was especially asked to evaluate the Gediz Delta Union model and learn about their experiences but also to explore the similarities about the management process of the Gediz Delta. During the fieldtrip several different stakeholder meetings were also organised for experience sharing. In accordance with our second project objective, the preparation of a guidebook about the Ramsar Sites in Turkey has been initiated. Initially it was planned to prepare a simple booklet about the Ramsar Sites in Turkey but after a series of consultation with the Ministry it has been decided that it would be a book that would give more details about the areas. This decision leads the project team to spend more time on the preparation, design and translation of the book. The book is expected to be finalised and published by late September – Early October 2010. The content of the book describes the values, issues, management planning process for each Ramsar Sites in Turkey. Under the 3rd objective of the project a fieldwork was carried out in two intervals to eight Ramsar Sites that are in the process of implementing their management plans. The first trip was made with the collaboration of Serhan Çağırankaya from the Ministry of Environment and Forestry, Melike Hemmami, Water Policy Coordinator of Doğa Derneği and Can Yeniyurt, Project Officer and Key Biodiversity Areas (KBA) Officer of Doğa Derneği. The first trip included Burdur Lake, Gediz Delta, Manyas Lake and Uluabat Lake. The second trip was made with the collaboration of Serhan Çağırankaya from the Ministry of Environment and Forestry, Esther Koopmanschap, Centre for Development Innovation also Ramsar CEPA Board Member, Melike Hemmami, Water Policy Coordinator of Doğa Derneği and Can Yeniyurt, Project Officer and Key Biodiversity Areas (KBA) Officer of Doğa Derneği. The second fieldtrip included Sultan Marshes, Yumurtalık Lagoons and the Göksu Delta. An additional trip was made by the Project Officer Can Yeniyurt to the Kızılırmak Delta. During both fieldtrip interviews were carried out with the Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry officers responsible for the implementation of the management plan in their area. Additionally, when possible other institutions and stakeholders were also consulted. Finally, the outputs of the interviews were shared in a meeting held in Samsun with all the Management Plans responsible staff members of the Provincial Directorates of the Ministry of Environment of all the Ramsar Sites in Turkey. The relevant NGOs representatives were also present in the workshop. The workshop was a success by ensuring the participation of 56 persons from different areas in Turkey. The workshop outputs were also included in the Ramsar Sites Management Plan evaluation report. 2. Achievements against each project objective In a separate page for each objective of the project, as stated in the project proposal, please indicate the output(s) in terms of: a) Task completed or b) Task only partially completed or c) Task not attempted and in addition, in the same page, please provide a summary of action(s) taken for each output. Objective 1. To increase public participation in management of Turkey's Ramsar Sites at local level – Kızılırmak Delta Ramsar Site model case a) Task Completed Output 1: Legal Kızılırmak Delta Ramsar Site Local Management System Following the kick-off meeting of the project in April 2009, in order to identify the appropriate local management structure for Kızılırmak Delta the Project Officer initiated a research, meetings and interviews with relevant stakeholders in the area of Wetlands Management Planning. In order to reach this aim, the first action undertaken was to evaluate the existing management structures in the Ramsar Sites with management plan in Turkey. Uluabat Lake Gediz Delta Burdur Lake Yumurtalık Lagoons Kızılırmak Delta Manyas Lake Sultan Marshes Göksu Delta An Uluabat lake Management Plan Steering Committee is set up under Bursa Local Wetland Commission. The meeting of this committee is constituted by local authorities and NGOs based in the region The implementation of the Gediz Delta Management Plan is undertaken by Izmir Bird Paradise Conservation and Development Union in coordination with the Provincial Directorate of MoEF. The finance of the Union is generated through the municipalities of the area which spare 1000/1 of their annual budget for the union. No specific body has been set up for the Management of the Burdur Lake. The decisions are made through the Burdur Local Wetlands Commission and the secretariat is undertaken by the Provincial Directorate of MoEF. A Steering Committee under the Adana Local Wetlands Commission is responsible of the implementation of the Yumurtalik Lagoons Management Plan which can set up a technical commission formed by expert wherever it might be needed. The Members of this commission are the staff of the Governorship, Municipalities of the area, Village Mukhtars (elected headman of the village), Water Products Kooperatives, Hunting club members. No specific Management Structure other than the Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry before this project. No specific Management Structure other than the Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry – However, the existence of a National Park Facility by the site create a different opportunity in terms of Communication and the Control of the site No specific Management Structure other than the Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry EPASA and Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry After the compilation of information related to different management structure these were evaluated together with the Wetlands Division of the MoEF and several NGOs (WWF Turkey, Bird Research Society - KAD) experienced in the area of Wetlands Management Planning in Turkey. The discussions were focused on the advantages and disadvantages of the existing structure and on how could this be developed further for better success in the implementation of Wetland Management Plans in Turkey (Activity 1.1). The outputs of these meetings and consultation process were then shared with relevant stakeholders in the Kızılırmak Delta such as the decision makers (Governorship of Samsun, Special Province Administration, Provincial Directorate of Environment and Forestry, Provincial Directorate of the Agriculture, State Hydraulic Works, Administrative District of Bafra, Administrative District of Ondokuzmayis District), but also stakeholders like Ondokuzmayis Hunting Club, Bafra Hunting Club, Municipality of Doganca, Municipality of Yorukler, headmen of the villages around the site. Furthermore, additional meetings were held at the Provincial Directorate of Environment and Forestry with the above-mentioned stakeholders for further discussions and the development of the best management structure idea for the Kızılırmak Delta (Activity 1.2). As a result of this consultation process the Local Wetlands Commission of Samsun Province decided to establish a Technical Commission for the Kızılırmak Delta in order to support the implementation of the Kızılırmak Delta Management Plan. The reason under the need of establishing such a technical commission was fed by the need of having a closer link with primary stakeholders in the area. The technical commission would also enable the land users to participate to the decision taking processes about the site and also would support the site to be managed together with the stakeholders. The members of the technical commission were; • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • The Head of the Administrative District of Bafra The Head of the Administrative District of Alaçam The Head of the Administrative District of Ondokuzmayıs The Faculty of Agriculture of Ondokuzmayıs University The Faculty of Science of Ondokuzmayıs University Provincial Directorate of State Hydraulic Works (DSI) Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs Provincial Commission for the Protection of Cultural and Natural Heritage Samsun Nature Protection Association The Municipality of Doğanca The Municipality of Yörükler Provincial Chamber of Agriculture Yörükler Water Products Cooperative Ondokuz Mayıs Hunting Club Bafra Hunting Club Special Provincial Administration The difference of this Commission compared to the Samsun Local Wetland Commission is the participation of the last 7 Members in the list above. The Commission meets at regular intervals (once in two months) and coordinates the implementation of management plan of the Delta. The next step undertaken in this project was to organise a study tour to the Gediz Delta together with 4 members (Governorship of Samsun, Municipality of Doganca, Provincial Directorate of Agriculture, Provincial Directorate of Environment and Forestry) of the newly set up technical commission. The aim of the visit was to create a ground for experience sharing among both sites. During three days, many meetings were held with different stakeholders of the Gediz Delta region. The Kızılırmak Delta Technical Commission members were especially impressed of the structure of the Union and how it was possible to generate finance through the Municipalities. Another impressive point was the coordination among the different stakeholders of the Delta by organising monthly meetings with all the parties involved in the management plan of the site. Many discussions were also made on the common problems face in both sites, these discussion raised the importance to foreseen some problems that might generate in the Kızılırmak Delta in the future. The fact of Gediz Delta being close to a big city like Izmir creates a lot of threats for the site. The technical commission realised the importance of taking preventive steps in order not to face the same problems in the Kızılırmak delta in the future. The visit also raised awareness on how to make use of the bird diversity as an added value for the region. This aspect of the Gediz Delta was thought of a good development to be used in the Kizilirmak Delta in order to create an opportunity to attract tourist to the site and making use of it as an income generating opportunity and the advantage of how the presence of a centre supports the attraction to the site. The period where the study tour was done the relations between the Provincial Directorate of MoEF and the Union was in very good terms also involving closely the NGOs of the region which was also a point that was valued by the Kızılırmak Delta Technical Commission. Another beneficial aspect of the visit was to see how one of the Technical Commission members had a change of attitude according what he saw in the Gediz Delta. It was the second visit of the Doganca Municipality Chief, the first time he visited the site, he had met a farmer dealing with husbandry complaining how it was no longer possible to do husbandry in the area because of the protected area status. However, this visit allowed the mayor to see how the problems related to husbandry were solved with dialogue. This information had an important impact on boosting certain prejudice on nature conservation activities (Activity 1.3). The agenda of the study visit can be found as attachment 2 and the participants list as attachment 3. In order to develop the Terms of Reference of the Kızılırmak Delta Technical Commission a meeting was organised before the Gediz Delta study visit in order to evaluate the existing different structure. This meeting resulted with the decision of accepting the implementation of the Kızılırmak Delta Management Plan as the main responsibility of the Technical Commission. This decision remained the same after the study visit to the Gediz Delta. However, the experience of the study visit was shared with the rest of the members as important points to take into consideration during the implementation of the Kızılırmak Delta Management Plan. The Study tour also underlined the importance of the role of the Provincial Directorate of MoEF as a secretariat which should be facilitating the coordination of different stakeholders but also to support the Technical Commission in their task (Activity 1.4). Finally, this activity had an impact on increasing the communication level with the Technical Commission members and the Provincial Directorate of MoEF. This communication process also created a basis on searching together finance opportunities like the Special Provincial Directorate of Administration of Samsun offering their opportunities to write proposals for the implementation of the Kızılırmak Delta Management Plan. The Kızılırmak Delta Technical Commission gathered 6 times from June 2009 - March 2010. The initial meetings were mainly to discuss the implementation and monitoring of the Kızılırmak Delta Management Plan. The first steps were to have presentations on what was so far implemented by different stakeholders. This also created an opportunity to share information among different stakeholders. The evaluation of this activities made by the Technical Commission were then presented to the Samsun Local Wetlands Commission (activity 1.5). The first decision taken with all the stakeholders after the end of the project was on agreeing on the construction of an interception channel planned under the Bafra plain left bank irrigation project. Objectives 2: To promote Ramsar sites’ values and public participation approaches in their management planning to central and local key stakeholders Task Partially Completed A small booklet was initially prepared last year in July including brief information on Ramsar Sites in Turkey. However, after many discussions with the Ministry of Environment and Forestry, Wetlands Division it has been decided that it would be more appropriate and useful to increase the content of the booklet in order allow more space to share the management planning process. This change requires more time for the preparation of the booklet and couldn’t be finalised so far. The book is expected to be published by Late September 2010 – Early October 2010. The content of the book will be as follow; • Description of Wetlands • The importance of Wetlands Ecosystems • The Ramsar Convention and Turkey • Ramsar Sites of Turkey • Sultan Marshes, Kuş Lake (Manyas), Seyfe Lake, Göksu Delta, Burdur Lake, Kızılırmak Delta, Uluabat Lake, Gediz Delta, Akyatan Lagoon, Yumurtalik Lagoons, Kızören Obruğu, Meke Maarı, Kuyucuk Lake. Each site will include a brief site definition, information on the management structure and it’s past. Up to this point, the areas which the contents are finalised are sent to the Ministry of Environment and Forestry, Wetlands Division for their approval and immediately sent for translation in English. The poster will also be prepared in the same period as according the discussions held with the Ministry it would be more appropriate to design a poster coherent with the booklet. Once both materials are published it will be shared with all the relevant stakeholders in the Ramsar Sites in Turkey but also different Ministries at Central Level. Objectives 3. To share Ramsar site management planning expertise throughout Turkey. Task Completed The activity has been initiated by making a research on different tools used for Management Plan Evaluation in order to develop/adapt a methodology for the assessment of the implemented Ramsar Site Management Plans in Turkey. Accordingly a quick assessment form including open ended questions were prepared for the fieldtrip (details on the methodologies are included in the fieldwork report). Eight Ramsar Sites were visited during this fieldwork with different experts as mentioned in the abstract of this report. Those areas were the Göksu Delta, Kus Lake (Manyas), Uluabat Lake, Gediz Delta, Kızılırmak Delta, Sultan Marshes, Yumurtalık Lagoons and the Burdur Lake. In each area, the Provincial Directorate of Ministry of Environment and Forestry responsible departments were visited and discussions about the implementation of Ramsar Sites Wetlands Management Plans were discussed. However, during the discussion the management plan development processes were also discussed (Activity 3.1). The fieldwork report including the meeting outcomes is about to be finalised and will soon be shared with relevant stakeholders. The English version of the report will also be sent to the Ramsar Secretariat once completed. The main issues in terms of implementing the Wetlands Management Plans that we encountered in most of the sites were the lack of knowledge on the wetland management planning process, the participation concept perceived in different levels and lack of capacity on biodiversity monitoring. Another issue often mentioned was the lack of financial resources and the frequent changes occurring in the Government staff resulting of new persons being responsible of the management plans implementation process without having a clear idea on the preparation process (Activity 3.2). Following an experience sharing workshop of two days has been organised in Samsun. The date of the workshop has been selected to also take the opportunity to celebrate the World Wetlands Days. All the Ramsar Site responsible government officers and several NGOs and University members working in different Ramsar Sites in Turkey were present in the meeting. For more information, the programme and the participants list is annexed to this report (Activity 3.3). The beginning of the meeting was mainly focused on the celebration of the World Wetlands Day where the Director of the Nature Conservation Department of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry, Mr. Ali Mennan Mennanoğulları honoured the meeting with an opening speech underlining the importance of wetlands ecosystem also by their services to the local communities in terms of economical benefits. Mr. Mennanoğulları also raised the importance of protecting the wetlands with regards the possible future water shortage threats. The director of the Provincial Directorate of the MoEF, Mr. Ömer Albayrak in his speech especially pointed out the importance of the Kızılırmak Delta as a Ramsar Site and the necessity of being able to protect the site for future generations. Finally, the Vice-Governor of Samsun, Ramazan Aksoy honoured the morning session with a speech on the importance of wetlands and his experience related the Sultan Marshes, the place where he originally comes from. The opening speeches were followed by various presentations on Ramsar Convention related activities in Turkey. The representative of the Ramsar secretariat Nadezhda Alexeeva presented a presentation on Wetland Management Planning and links with the Ramsar Convention. The afternoon session was allocated for group working on discussions about the main topics that emerged from the fieldtrip interviews. The participants divided on different topics such as monitoring, legislation, participation, finance and land use pressure to discuss the common problems of different sites followed by discussion on the possible solutions and finally the necessary management structure to address these issues. The outputs of the meeting have been integrated within the Ramsar Site Management Plans Implementation report (Activity 3.4). The programme and participants list of the meeting is annexed to this report. The second day of the meeting was allocated to a field visit in the Kızılırmak Delta where the participants from different Ramsar Sites were able to see the Kızılırmak Delta but also the facilities of the National Parks that newly has been constructed to undertake activities targeting the visitors. 3. Overall project outcomes Overall, has the project achieved what it set out to do? Yes If No, please indicate the reasons for failing to meet the overall objective. Please provide information about two or three lessons learned in the implementation of the Project. It would have been beneficial to have invited the managers of the Gediz Delta to the Kızılırmak Delta in order to have more members of the technical commission benefiting from their management experience The workshop organised in Samsun showed the importance of bringing together the managers of different Ramsar Sites to enable them to share their experiences but also discuss their common problems which could need a more collective approach to find solutions. 4. Recommendations for future follow-up and conclusions The Wetlands Management Plans in Turkey are often prepared by NGOs, Companies and in some cases by Government Officers from the Central Level. The time limit for the development of a plan is maximum 3 years. However, the implementation of the plan is left to the Provincial Directorate of MoEF. The feedback received during the field interviews shows that the parties have serious difficulties to implement and understand the logic of the management planning process and accordingly faces difficulties to coordinate the implementation. Once a management plan is developed for a site it is vital to ensure 2-3 years support to the site in terms management planning logic and tools that would contribute to its successful implementation. The lack of sufficient staff in the local directorates has important impacts for monitoring activities. The project showed once again the importance of developing upper level strategy that could impact the National Policies to allocate sufficient staff to undertake monitoring activity. The main reasons of the problems encountered in the Ramsar Sites of Turkey are caused by wrong irrigation techniques used in Agricultural lands and the pollution created by these lands. It is vital to develop ideas/projects in order to solve these problems. Most of the Management Plans in Turkey are not easily implemented because of the lack of financial resources. The development of projects to implement certain activities existing in the management plan could be a good opportunity to support the implementation of the management plans. Many projects were implemented in Turkey in order to raise awareness and increase capacity on participatory approaches in the development process of wetlands management plans. The evaluation of different management plans in the course of time does show important improvements in terms of the increase of attempts to develop plans in a more participatory way. However, the perception on the level of participation is still not sufficient for the successful implementation of the plans as it was not possible to see a general ownership feeling of the plan by different stakeholders in most of the sites. Supporting activities that improve participation comes out as an important point for the future. 5. Budgetary details Please submit a detailed expenditure and income account referring to the original Project budget. Indicate expenditure and income in the currency(s) in which they have actually occurred, and as necessary provide the exchange rate into Swiss Francs to be applied. Please attach a separate finance report table (preferably in Excel or Word) which presents all the expenditures in the categories of the original budget, as well as a summary table with the totals by category. Were all funds allocated to the project from the WFF spent in accordance with the project specifications and approved budget? Yes The detailed Budget Report is provided as Attachment - 6 6. Project Officer (person responsible for executing the project) Name: Can Yeniyurt Institution: Doga Dernegi Address: Hürriyet Cad. 43/12 Dikmen / Ankara / Turkey 06460 Signature: Date: 7. General Director of Doga Dernegi Name: Bahtiyar Kurt Institution: Doga Dernegi Address: Hürriyet Cad. 43/12 Dikmen / Ankara / Turkey 06460 Signature: Date: 8. Approved by the Ramsar Administrative Authority Name: Yaşar Dostbil Signature: Administrative Authority: General Directorate of Nature Conservation and National Parks Ministry of Environment and Forestry Date: Address: Söğütözü Cad. No: 14 / E Kat: 14 / Ankara /Turkey 06560 Attachment -1 Summary Project Turkey has declared 12 Ramsar Sites since 1994 upon ratification of Ramsar convention with a total surface area of 179.773 ha. In 2002 “The Regulation on The Conservation of Wetlands” was entered in the force (and revised in 2005) by The Ministry of Environment and Forestry. Up to now, the Management Plans of 6 Ramsar sites was entered in to force, nowadays for 2 Ramsar Sites Management Plans are prepared. Additionally, in 2003 National Wetland Strategy (20032008) was accepted and is being implemented. It has been experienced that in Turkey implementation of management plans need a local management system for effective management and monitoring of these sites. There is a need to encourage establishment of local management systems in all Ramsar sites and other wetlands for wise use of wetlands. Ramsar sites, their values and participatory systems in management are not well-known enough by key stakeholders. There is a need to publish and widely distribute informational materials on Turkey’s Ramsar sites and their values. Since 1994, Turkey has been party to the Ramsar Convention, local and central ministerial experts gained experience in management planning and monitoring of wetlands. For wise use of wetlands in Turkey, there is a need to share this experience throughout Turkey through a meeting and report. This project’s aim objective is to enhance effective conservation of Turkey's Ramsar sites. This project proposal addresses these specific objectives in Ramsar Strategic Plan 2003-2008 operational objectives: 1. To increase public participation in management of Turkey's Ramsar Sites at local level Kızılırmak Delta Ramsar Site model case (Operational Objective 11 through enhancing establishment of local management systems in Ramsar sites as cross-sectoral management committees) 2. To promote Ramsar sites’ values and public participation approaches in their management planning to central and local key stakeholders (Operational Objective 6 through well known values of Ramsar sites by related stakeholders) 3. To share Ramsar site management planning expertise throughout Turkey Operational Objective 14 through experience share in management planning and monitoring of Turkey’s Ramsar sites) First specific objective will be implemented in Kızılırmak Delta Ramsar site, which is one of the most important delta ecosystems in Black Sea coast. Management plan of this site has been finalized in 2007 with Ministry of Environment and Forestry and Doga Dernegi’s close cooperation. Kızılırmak Delta local management system will be the main responsible body for effective implementation and monitoring of this management plan for many years. DD will continue to play its main role in Kızılırmak Delta management plan activities and assist local management system members. The Ramsar site booklets and posters will be used by many stakeholders to inform their members for many years. Turkey’s Ramsar site management planning lessons learnt report will be the main resource for current management planning activities in Turkey. As the NGO member of the National Wetland Commission in Turkey, DD will follow up the results of the project and use and lobby for its results for the wise use of wetlands in Turkey. Attachment - 2 Under Objective 3: Sharing Ramsar site management planning expertise and information in Turkey’s experience with other wetlands in Turkey Gediz Delta Experience Sharing Visit Dates: 22nd, 23rd and 24th of July 2009 22nd of July, 2009 – Arrival to Izmir 23rd July 2009 09.00 – 09.15 Opening speech 09.15 – 09.30 Project presentation, Doga Dernegi 09.30 – 10.00 Gediz Delta presentation, Doga Dernegi 10.00 – 11.00 Gediz Delta Management Plan, Izmir Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry Office 11.00 – 11.15 Coffee break 11.15 – 12.15 Management Plan Implementation Process, Protection and Development Union of Izmir Bird Paradise 12.30–14.00 Lunch 14.00–15.30 Gediz Delta Field trip 24 July 2009 - Departure Attachment -3 Participation List of the Gediz Delta Experience Sharing Visit Date : 23 July 2009 Location : Đzmir, Gediz Delta Name Foundation Phone E-mail Ali Aydın Đzmir Provincial Directorate +905323635133 aliaydin09@gmail.com of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry Durmuş Yıldız Samsun Provincial Directorate +903622313700 durmusyildiz_1952@yahoo.com of the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs Fatih Bulut Samsun Provincial Directorate +905388591566 fatihbulut55@hotmail.com of Environment and Forestry Đsmail Mutlu The Municipality of Doğanca +905323714837 Imutlu-55@hotmail.com Nilsun Ege Đzmir Provincial Directorate +902323696485 nilsunpolat@mynet.com Polat of the Ministry of +905374257895 dondurenomer@mynet.com +905326322202 selinkoptu@yahoo.com +905325046430 semaariman@gmail.com Environment and Forestry Ömer Izmir Bird Paradise Döndüren Conservation and Development Union Selin Koptu Đzmir Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry Sema Arıman Samsun Province Special Provincial Administration Attachment -4 Programme of the “National Ramsar Site Management Experience Sharing” Meeting World Wetlands Day " National Ramsar Site Management Experience Sharing Meeting " 2-3 February 2010 2 February 2010 / Tuesday Samsun / Ondokuzmayıs University Tepe Hotel Time Content Speakers 09:00 Registration Ramazan AKSOY, Governorship of Samsun Ali Mennan MENNANOĞULLARI, 9:30 Opening Speeches Ministry of Environment and Forestry Ömer ALBAYRAK , Provincial Directorate of Environment and Forestry Melike HEMMAMĐ, Doğa Derneği “Voice of the Wetlands” Video 10:00 Show Activities related to the Ramsar 10:15 Convention in Turkey Effective Management of Ramsar 10:40 Sites in Turkey Project 11:00 Coffee Break Ministry of Environment and Forestry Serhan ÇAĞIRANKAYA, Ministry of Environment and Forestry Melike HEMMAMĐ, Doğa Derneği Nadezhda ALEXEEVA, Ramsar Convention The Ramsar Convention and 11:30 Wetlands Management Planning 12:00 Kızılırmak Delta 12:30 Lunch National Ramsar Site Management 13:30 Experience Sharing Question & Answer 15:00 Coffee Break Secretariat Ömer ALBAYRAK, Provincial Directorate of Environment and Forestry Group work National Ramsar Site Management 15:30 Experience Sharing Question & Answer Group work 18:00 Closure 19:00 Dinner 3 February 2010 / Wednesday - Samsun / Kızılırmak Delta 09:00 12:00 13:30 17:00 Departure Lunch Kızılırmak Delta Field Visit Arrival Attachment -5 Participants Lists of the “National Ramsar Site Management Experience Sharing” Meeting No Name Foundation 1 Abdullah Sevinç Provincial Directorate of Environment and Forestry 2 Ahmet Aydın Yörükler Water Products Cooperative 3 Ahmet Ulusoy Bafra Hunting Club 4 Ali Mennan Mennanoğulları Ministry of Environment and Forestry 5 Alpay Tırıl Sinop University 6 Evrim Sönmez Interpreter 7 Ayhan Arıkan Kırşehir Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry 8 Ayhan Boyacı The Head of the Administrative District of Bafra 9 Berrin Tanrınur Samsun Provincial Directorate of Environment and Forestry 10 Can Yeniyurt Doğa Derneği 11 Deniz Güler Egedoğa Association 12 Durmuş Yıldız 13 Elif Okumuş Samsun Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs Wetlands Division, Ministry of Environment and Forestry 14 Ergin Öztürk The Faculty of Agriculture of Ondokuzmayıs University Ersan Berberoğlu Burdur Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry 16 Fatih Bulut Samsun Provincial Directorate of Environment and Forestry 17 Ferrah Çakır Balıkesir Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry 18 Fikret Coşuner Samsun Provincial Directorate of Environment and Forestry 19 Galena Đş World Wildlife Fund (WWF-Turkey) 20 Gökhan Hacıömeroğlu Samsun Provincial Directorate of State Hydraulic Works 15 The Faculty of Science of Ondokuzmayıs University 21 Gülsüm Mumcu 22 Hakan Arslan Samsun Provincial Directorate of State Hydraulic Works Hayri Öztürk Samsun Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs 24 Hidayet Topçu Bursa Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry 25 Đhan Cin Samsun Provincial Directorate of the Agriculture 26 Đlker Özbahar Turkish Bird Research Society 27 Đsa Eroğlu S.S. Yörükler Agicultural Development Cooperative 23 The Head of the Administrative District of Ondokuzmayıs 28 Kadir Ekinci Kiraz Erciyas Ornithological Research Center Ondokuz Mayis University Mazlume Mazlumoğlu Adana Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry 31 Mehmet Şener Konya Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry 32 Melike Hemmami Doğa Derneği 33 Menderes Alan 34 Murat Demir Samsun Provincial Commission for the Protection of Cultural and Natural Heritage Samsun Provincial Directorate of Environment and Forestry 35 Murat Doğanay Kars Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry 36 Murat Saraç Samsun Provincial Directorate of State Hydraulic Works Mustafa Kurtulan Mersin Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry 38 Muzaffer Çelik Samsun Provincial Directorate of Environment and Forestry 39 Nadezhda Alexeeva Ramsar Convention Secretariat 29 30 37 Nagehan Acır Adana Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry Necat Đnce Đzmir Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry Nuran Yılmaz Samsun Provincial Directorate of Environment and Forestry Ömer Albayrak Samsun Provincial Directorate of Environment and Forestry 44 Ömer Döndüren Izmir Bird Paradise Conservation and Development Union 45 Önder Cırık Kuzeydoğa Association 46 Özden Sağlam Samsun Nature Protection Association 47 Ramazan Aksoy Governorship of Samsun 48 Savaş Yılmaz The Faculty of Science of Ondokuzmayıs University 49 Selman Çubukoğlu Samsun Provincial Directorate of State Hydraulic Works 50 Sema Arıman Samsun Province Special Provincial Administration 51 Senem Üstün Kurnaz Samsun Provincial Directorate of State Hydraulic Works Serhan Çağırankaya Wetlands Division, Ministry of Environment and Forestry 53 Süreyya Özdemir Environmental Protection Agency for Special Areas, Ministry of Environment and Forestry 54 Sezgin Üçüncü The Head of the Administrative District of Alaçam Şevket Ağmaz Kayseri Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Environment and Forestry Yekta Özkan Samsun Provincial Directorate of the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs 40 41 42 43 52 55 56 Attachment -6 Finance Report Doğa Derneği Effective Management of Ramsar Sites in Turkey 02/04/2009 – 02/04/2010 DOCUMENT HISTORY DOCUMENT NUMBER EXPLANATION TL CHF AMOUNT AMOUNT* 1. SALARIES / WAGES / CONSULTANCY COSTS 1.1 Supervisory Staff 30.04.2009 31.05.2009 30.06.2009 ÖZGE BALKIZ APRİL ÖZGE BALKIZ MAY ÖZGE BALKIZ JUNE 1.1 Supervisory Staff Total 2.814,95 2.918,28 2.992,45 2365,50 2452,34 2514,66 8725,68 7332,50 1.300,00 1092,44 1.2 Consultants / Experts 28.10.2009 84 NESLİHAN ÖZGÜNEŞ 1.2 Consultants / Experts Total 1300,00 1092,44 1.3 Office Staff 1.3 Office Staff Total 1. SALARIES / WAGES / CONSULTANCY COSTS TOTAL 0,00 0,00 10025,68 8424,94 2. TRAVEL & ACCOMMODATION COSTS 2.1 Air fares 26.06.2009 25.07.2009 25.07.2009 12.01.2010 14517 14609 14610 885524 ELİT TURİZM ELİT TURİZM ELİT TURİZM ANADOLU JET 2.1 Air fares Total 183,00 129,00 129,00 59,00 153,78 108,40 108,40 49,58 500,00 420,17 2.2 Other travel costs 02.04.2009 02.04.2009 14.04.2009 18.04.2009 26.04.2009 28.04.2009 17.05.2009 17.05.2009 18.05.2009 14.07.2009 35580 227530 126157 337362 35580 44525 167570 166918 627317 352453291570 VARAN TURİZM MEHMET KARAKAYA TURGUT ÜLKER VARAN TURİZM MURAT TAMAR AYHAN KOÇAL HAVAŞ HAVAŞ EKREM TANCAN ANADOLU JET 38,00 13,00 20,00 38,00 20,00 20,00 7,00 7,00 35,00 89,00 31,93 10,92 16,81 31,93 16,81 16,81 5,88 5,88 29,41 74,79 21.07.2009 22.07.2009 23.07.2009 24.07.2009 25.07.2009 25.07.2009 25.07.2009 02.08.2009 10.09.2009 26.10.2009 08.11.2009 08.11.2009 08.11.2009 09.11.2009 09.11.2009 11.11.2009 11.11.2009 13.11.2009 14.11.2009 14.11.2009 19.11.2009 05.01.2010 05.01.2010 05.01.2010 05.01.2010 08.01.2010 08.01.2010 10.01.2010 10.01.2010 10.01.2010 10.01.2010 10.01.2010 10.01.2010 11.01.2010 11.01.2010 11.01.2010 12.01.2010 12.01.2010 12.01.2010 12.01.2010 14.01.2010 14.01.2010 14.01.2010 15.01.2010 18.01.2010 171555 227791 59737 611855 14614 14613 14611 274574 418493 459875 679428 679429 169326 684151 2 535 9 12 35 7 67 718977 82317 817242 352129 968012 351733 752024 752025 752022 752023 303245 25334 269339 3 2 99251 97625 328685 16 5018 4027 28 20 72 EFENDİ EŞİYOK HAVAŞ VARAN TURİZM AYŞE ŞAŞAL ELİT TURİZM ELİT TURİZM ELİT TURİZM KAMİL KOÇ TURİZM SEYAHAT EMİR ABDULLAH GÖKDEMİR HAVAŞ KAMİL KOÇ KAMİL KOÇ SEMA SILBIYIK KAMİL KOÇ BAHTAŞ BURDUR AKARYAKIT İZELMAN OTOPARK ABAŞ PROJE İNŞ VE PETROL ÖZDEMİRLER PETROL BEĞENDİK YAY PETROL TE.TİC.SAN.LTD ŞEKER SHELL HAVAŞ HAVAŞ ANADOLU JET SÜLEYMAN KATAR VARAN TURİZM SEYAHAT RAMAZAN YÜKSEL KAMİL KOÇ KAMİL KOÇ KAMİL KOÇ KAMİL KOÇ HARUN ÖCAL YÜKSEL KALENDER ALİ ŞENAY BAHTAŞ ŞEVKET ÖZMEN PET.NK.GD. HAVAŞ SÜHA ŞEHİRLERARASI OTOBÜS AŞIR AKDENİZ POYRAZ PETROL K.G.M K.G.M TOROS TAR.SAN.TİC TŞOF TRAFİK ARAÇ VE GEREÇ ŞEKER SHELL 15,00 10,00 67,00 10,00 149,00 263,00 263,00 45,00 18,00 10,00 30,00 30,00 40,00 30,00 135,02 4,50 105,02 68,99 4,00 99,04 35,00 7,50 10,00 59,00 50,00 37,00 30,00 30,00 30,00 30,00 30,00 20,00 20,00 10,00 120,01 114,99 10,00 21,00 15,00 100,00 2,00 2,00 110,00 128,01 91,50 12,61 8,40 56,30 8,40 125,21 221,01 221,01 37,82 15,13 8,40 25,21 25,21 33,61 25,21 113,46 3,78 88,25 57,97 3,36 83,23 29,41 6,30 8,40 49,58 42,02 31,09 25,21 25,21 25,21 25,21 25,21 16,81 16,81 8,40 100,85 96,63 8,40 17,65 12,61 84,03 1,68 1,68 92,44 107,57 76,89 19.01.2010 19.01.2010 25.01.2010 25.01.2010 25.01.2010 31.01.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 02.02.2010 02.02.2010 02.02.2010 02.02.2010 02.02.2010 02.02.2010 02.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 04.02.2010 04.02.2010 15.02.2010 16.02.2010 20.03.2010 20.03.2010 21276 646218 410885 194470 992198 114421 171557 17434 31470 337306 337304 337305 558441 335114 190224 356501 27782 4183 128337 387243 387242 387241 4018 338509 338508 194216 370568 4334 244178 318384 130411 921556 339 FAİK ARSLAN RECEP KANDEMİR MEHMET ÖZTÜRK ABDURAHMAN KATAR HASAN SÖZCÜ LÜKS ANI TUR İSA ÇATALKAYA DURAN YARIZ ÖZKAYMAK AHMET DEMİRTAŞ AHMET DEMİRTAŞ AHMET DEMİRTAŞ BİROL TÜRK AYHAN BÜLBÜL ÖMER ARI METRO TURİZM METRO TURİZM VARAN KONSET HAVAŞ HAVAŞ HAVAŞ VARAN TURİZM MURAT KOÇ MURAT KOÇ DURALI DEMİR AHMET ERDEN BEYŞEHİR SEYAHAT İBRAHİM KOYUNCU YENER ÇETİN ARİF BARUĞ ANADOLU DOĞA TURİZM OSKA PETROL 2.2 Other travel costs Total 16,50 15,00 15,00 15,00 17,00 413,00 9,50 100,00 25,00 50,00 50,00 50,00 60,00 45,00 15,00 50,00 50,00 37,00 48,00 10,00 10,00 10,00 65,00 45,00 45,00 40,00 13,00 8,00 95,00 12,00 20,00 106,50 39,34 4396,42 13,87 12,61 12,61 12,61 14,29 347,06 7,98 84,03 21,01 42,02 42,02 42,02 50,42 37,82 12,61 42,02 42,02 31,09 40,34 8,40 8,40 8,40 54,62 37,82 37,82 33,61 10,92 6,72 79,83 10,08 16,81 89,50 33,06 3694,47 2.3 Accommodation 18.05.2009 23.07.2009 23.07.2009 11.11.2009 13.11.2009 14.11.2009 11.01.2010 160735 303577 303578 116376 45164 70872 79169 ANADOLU EVLERİ İZMİR KARŞIYAKA ÖĞRETMENEVİ İZMİR KARŞIYAKA ÖĞRETMENEVİ TARIM VE KÖYİŞLERİ BAK. KARACABEY ÖĞRETMENEVİ İNEGÖL ÖĞRETMENEVİ ERCİYES ÜNİVERSİTESİ TALAS 110,00 197,00 210,00 150,00 80,00 67,00 120,00 92,44 165,55 176,47 126,05 67,23 56,30 100,84 13.01.2010 15.01.2010 15.01.2010 20.03.2010 31.03.2010 19969 371565 15620 921557 921558 TAKAV GÖKSU OTEL ÖZTUR OTEL ANADOLU DOĞA TURİZM ANADOLU DOĞA TURİZM 2.3 Accommodation Total 140,00 150,00 90,00 74,49 3.800,00 5188,49 117,65 126,05 75,63 62,60 3193,28 4360,08 2.4 Meals 19.04.2009 20.04.2009 21.04.2009 21.04.2009 22.04.2009 23.04.2009 24.04.2009 25.04.2009 26.04.2009 29.04.2009 29.04.2009 22.07.2009 22.07.2009 22.07.2009 22.07.2009 22.07.2009 23.07.2009 23.07.2009 23.07.2009 23.07.2009 23.07.2009 23.07.2009 24.07.2009 03.09.2009 16.09.2009 16.09.2009 08.11.2009 09.11.2009 09.11.2009 10.11.2009 10.11.2009 11.11.2009 11.11.2009 11.11.2009 11.11.2009 11.11.2009 28 11 7319 7318 421 108 98 36 10 149 7 33 7 34 12 982834 200 201 17 196 140 61 6 150 4 26 11 14 164 128 677461 1 15 6 5 51 AKYÜZ SAADET DÖNER TATCAN KURUYEMİŞ TATCAN KURUYEMİŞ AKYÜZ AKYÜZ OMKAN İKT.İŞL. AKYÜZ ÇEŞNİ TURŞU LİMAN BÜFE TEYZENİN YERİ KYAKA ÖĞRETMENEVİ KADRİYE USLU KYAKA ÖĞRETMENEVİ LEVTUR TUR. AYDIN KARA LOKAL GIDA LOKAL GIDA DEDE BİLİŞİM TURİZM LOKAL GIDA EGE ÜNİVERSİTESİ KYAKA ÖĞRETMENEVİ LOKANTA MEHMET NACİ OSKA PETROL ÜRÜN İNS.TAAH. PİDECİ LİVA PASTANESİ HAZAL GIDA TİC.LTD ŞTİ ÖZSARI TOP VE PAR GIDA SAN. MİGROS TİCARET A.Ş BARINAK CAFE ÖMER USTANIN YERİ KAYA RESTORAN ADEM USTA GIDA.PAZ.SAN OSMAN ERŞEN ÇAY OCAĞI İŞL OSMAN ERŞEN ÇAY OCAĞI İŞL FOTOCAN GIDA İŞL 6,90 9,25 30,00 35,00 20,14 7,97 3,15 5,76 3,00 5,00 12,50 3,00 20,00 3,00 160,00 200,00 54,50 22,25 16,00 25,00 11,20 4,00 23,00 25,00 32,50 18,94 6,00 72,00 34,32 114,50 35,00 5,00 40,00 5,00 5,00 56,50 5,80 7,77 25,21 29,41 16,92 6,70 2,65 4,84 2,52 4,20 10,50 2,52 16,81 2,52 134,45 168,07 45,80 18,70 13,45 21,01 9,41 3,36 19,33 21,01 27,31 15,92 5,04 60,50 28,84 96,22 29,41 4,20 33,61 4,20 4,20 47,48 11.11.2009 12.11.2009 12.11.2009 12.11.2009 12.11.2009 13.11.2009 13.11.2009 14.11.2009 05.01.2010 05.01.2010 06.01.2010 06.01.2010 06.01.2010 06.01.2010 06.01.2010 06.01.2010 07.01.2010 08.01.2010 08.01.2010 08.01.2010 11.01.2010 11.01.2010 11.01.2010 11.01.2010 12.01.2010 12.01.2010 12.01.2010 12.01.2010 12.01.2010 12.01.2010 13.01.2010 13.01.2010 13.01.2010 13.01.2010 14.01.2010 14.01.2010 14.01.2010 14.01.2010 14.01.2010 14.01.2010 15.01.2010 31.03.2010 2.4 Meals Total 4 645 636 6 10 21 1 1 11 38 74 6 3 574 18 73 7 8 3 2 2 23 2 1 10 13 2 3 4 53 10 11 1 19 10 3 5 108 107 4 17 921559 KAYA RESTORAN BEYAZ FIRIN GIDA MAĞZACILIK BEYAZ FIRIN GIDA MAĞZACILIK CANCAN MARKET MEYDAN LOKANTASI BESLER İNEGÖL KÖFTECİSİ PEHLİVAN CAFE RESTORAN MESUT DONDURMA BURGER KİNG HASAN TAYİNCİOĞLI MADO SEVGİ CAFE ELİT UNLU GIDA SİMİT CENTER MADO MADO EYLENSEL RESTAURANT PATRON CAFE CAY YÖREM PİDE LAHMACUN YÖREM PİDE LAHMACUN ŞEVKET ÖZMEN PET.NK.GD. KAŞIKLA MANTI RESTAURANT KATE GIDA VE UNLU S.S.TARIMSAL KALKINMA KOOP HELVACI PETROL ÖZTÜRKLER ET LOKANTASI ÇAVDARLAR PETROL SAN. ÇAVDARLAR PETROL SAN. ÇAVDARLAR PETROL SAN. METROL İKRAM PAZARLAMA PAŞAM MARKET PAŞAM MARKET ZEYTİNALTI RESTAURANT BABANIN YERİ GÖZDE GIDA ÜRÜN İMALAT GÖKSEL 1 GID.İLET. GÖKSEL 1 GID.İLET. TOROS TAR.SAN.TİC TOROS TAR.SAN.TİC GÖKSEL 1 GID.İLET. EYLENSEL RESTAURANT ANADOLU DOĞA TURİZM 5,00 8,75 7,05 2,50 27,00 55,00 43,00 13,00 14,25 19,50 23,50 6,00 6,00 3,00 25,00 25,50 45,00 15,00 40,00 40,00 25,00 74,25 30,00 10,00 70,00 50,00 5,00 11,00 9,00 13,50 18,50 1,85 15,00 50,00 120,00 40,00 20,00 1,00 3,50 40,00 41,00 2.800,00 5003,03 4,20 7,35 5,92 2,10 22,69 46,22 36,13 10,92 11,97 16,39 19,75 5,04 5,04 2,52 21,01 21,43 37,82 12,61 33,61 33,61 21,01 62,39 25,21 8,40 58,82 42,02 4,20 9,24 7,56 11,34 15,55 1,55 12,61 42,02 100,84 33,61 16,81 0,84 2,94 33,61 34,45 2352,94 4204,23 2. TRAVEL & ACCOMMODATION COSTS 15087,94 12678,94 3. RAMSAR SECRETARIAT PROJECT VISIT: TRAVEL & ACCOMMODATION COSTS 3.1 Air fares 26.01.2010 110887 TÜRK HAVA YOLLARI 3.1 Air fares Total 143,00 120,17 143,00 120,17 3.2 Other travel costs 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 04.02.2010 366567 366359 303257 337067 200527 8 HAVAŞ HAVAŞ HARUN ÖCAL ALİ RIZA ÇAĞLAR SAMİYE YAMAN YETO YEŞİL ENERJİ TEKNOLOJİ 3.2 Other travel costs Total 10,00 10,00 15,00 10,00 16,00 56,54 117,54 8,40 8,40 12,61 8,40 13,45 47,51 98,77 3.3 Accommodation & meals 03.02.2010 04.02.2010 23630 17214 TEPE OTEL ELİT PALAS 3.3 Accommodation & meals Total 3. RAMSAR SECRETARIAT PROJECT VISIT: TRAVEL & ACCOMMODATION COSTS TOTAL 500,00 118,00 420,17 99,16 618,00 519,33 878,54 738,27 4. EQUIPMENT: PURCHASE, HIRE & RUNNING COSTS 4.1 Hiring vehicles 22.07.2009 06.10.2009 22.04.2009 17846 25 13 ZEPLİN TURİZM FİLİZ OTOMOTİV ŞEFEK PETROL 4.1 Hiring vehicles Total 450,00 25,00 25,04 378,15 21,01 21,04 500,04 420,20 20,00 100,04 190,03 16,81 84,07 159,69 4.2 Fuel & maintenance 10.04.2009 21.04.2009 22.07.2009 93 163777 7 4.2 Fuel & maintenance Total CEM PETROL UZUN PETROL ÖLMEZ KARDEŞLER 310,07 260,56 4. EQUIPMENT: PURCHASE, HIRE & RUNNING COSTS TOTAL 810,11 680,76 5. OFFICE RUNNING COSTS (of DD Ankara central office) 5.1 Computer costs 0,00 0,00 5.1 Computer costs Total 0,00 0,00 5.2 Telephone & fax 30.04.2009 19.07.2009 07.08.2009 18.11.2009 24.03.2010 25.03.2010 28.04.2010 29 42 8 11 944606 23 816352 KEFELİ İNŞAAT CANTEL İLET. TEKİN İLETİŞİM AS İLETİŞİM TÜRK TELEKOM CARREFOUR EXPRES TÜRK TELEKOM 5.2 Telephone & fax Total 18,00 28,00 44,00 30,00 148,22 308,00 21,61 597,83 15,13 23,53 36,97 25,21 124,55 258,82 18,16 502,38 5.3 Photocopies 04.02.2010 22.03.2010 11190 11251 PASAJ KIRTASİYE PASAL KIRTASİYE 5.3 Photocopies Total 162,25 315,00 477,25 136,34 264,71 401,05 5.4 Office supplies 19.04.2009 20.04.2009 20.04.2009 21.04.2009 22.04.2009 01.12.2009 31.03.2010 6 3 10 5 1 11064 11 YENİ ÇARŞI YURTSEVER COLOR YENİ ÇARŞI YENİ ÇARŞI BAHAR TİCARET PASAJ KIRTASİYE TEKNOSA İÇ VE DIŞ TİC. 5.4 Office supplies Total 6,00 6,00 10,00 3,00 2,00 256,06 59,90 5,04 5,04 8,40 2,52 1,68 215,18 50,34 342,96 288,20 0,00 1418,04 0,00 1191,63 5.5 Other (please specify): Office rent 5.5 Other (please specify): Office rent 5. OFFICE RUNNING COSTS (of DD Ankara central office) TOTAL 6. COST OF PUBLICATIONS, VIDEOS/DVDs, CDs etc. 6.1 Preparation 27.03.2010 81686 EMRE OFSET 6.1 Preparation Total 4.000,00 3361,34 4000,00 3361,34 8.000,40 6723,03 6.2 Printing / reproduction 27.03.2010 81687 EMRE OFSET 6.2 Printing / reproduction Total 8000,40 6723,03 6.3 Distribution (postage) 28.10.2009 11.03.2010 11.03.2010 17.03.2010 18.03.2010 18.03.2010 18.03.2010 24.03.2010 25.03.2010 26.03.2010 31.03.2010 31.03.2010 192024 817766 817752 845568 276685 276830 818108 1058050467 24793 818465 139308 461751 ARAS KARGO ARAS KARGO ARAS KARGO YURTİÇİ KARGO YURTİÇİ KARGO YURTİÇİ KARGO ARAS KARGO PTT KARGO YURTİÇİ KARGO ARAS KARGO PTT PTT 6.3 Distribution (postage) Total 6. COST OF PUBLICATIONS, VIDEOS/DVDs, CDs etc.TOTAL 26,63 47,99 8,26 7,27 6,68 8,07 21,18 3,00 6,68 4,13 800,00 5,05 22,38 40,33 6,94 6,11 5,61 6,78 17,80 2,52 5,61 3,47 672,27 4,24 944,94 794,07 12945,34 10878,44 7. COST OF WORKSHOP(S)/ TRAINING COURSE(S) 7.1 Air fares 05.01.2010 21.01.2010 26.01.2010 26.01.2010 26.01.2010 26.01.2010 26.01.2010 817241 293085 610346 610345 610878 610880 610879 7.1 Air fares Total 7.2 Transportation ANADOLU JET PEGASUS HAVAYOLLARI TÜRK HAVA YOLLARI TÜRK HAVA YOLLARI TÜRK HAVA YOLLARI TÜRK HAVA YOLLARI TÜRK HAVA YOLLARI 59,00 138,99 59,00 59,00 143,00 143,00 143,00 49,58 116,80 49,58 49,58 120,17 120,17 120,17 744,99 626,04 29.01.2010 30.01.2010 31.01.2010 31.01.2010 31.01.2010 31.01.2010 31.01.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 01.02.2010 02.02.2010 02.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 04.02.2010 06.02.2010 16.02.2010 643230 322845 142568 12727 12728 12729 142859 114702 544836 544835 23835 443443 146456 202469 250131 93958 273814 265576 104150 871952 923469 104127 230267 129805 3 132014 273816 280959 440281 871953 387270 26825 99880 26826 418090 26124 25 ŞANAL KIRŞEHİR NİLÜFER TURİZM NEVŞEHİRLİLER TURİZM VARAN TURİZM VARAN TURİZM VARAN TURİZM METRO TURİZM DOĞA KARADENİZ ULUSOY TİCARET TUR. ULUSOY TİCARET TUR. BAFRA AYDOĞAN TURİZM LÜKS ARTVİN HAVAŞ METRO TURİZM LİDER TURİZM ULUSOY TİCARET TUR. ULUSOY TİCARET TUR. ULUSOY TİCARET TUR. METRO TURİZM ULUSOY TİCARET TUR. HAS TURİZM SEYAHAT METRO TURİZM ULUSOY TİCARET TUR. BAFRA AYDOĞAN TURİZM CİLBOĞLU ŞEKERLEME BAFRA AYDOĞAN TURİZM ULUSOY TİCARET TUR. ULUSOY TİCARET TUR. ULUSOY TİCARET TUR. ULUSOY TİCARET TUR. HAVAŞ METRO TURİZM LİDER TURİZM METRO TURİZM KAMİL KOÇ METRO TURİZM ARGOLD KUY.TEL. 7.2 Transportation Total 13,00 35,00 35,00 37,00 37,00 37,00 50,00 25,00 37,00 37,00 50,00 45,00 8,00 55,00 50,00 60,00 41,00 41,00 30,00 50,00 55,00 30,00 38,00 60,00 50,00 50,00 37,00 51,00 31,00 43,00 10,00 50,00 30,00 40,00 40,00 40,00 31,00 1459,00 10,92 29,41 29,41 31,09 31,09 31,09 42,02 21,01 31,09 31,09 42,02 37,82 6,72 46,22 42,02 50,42 34,45 34,45 25,21 42,02 46,22 25,21 31,93 50,42 42,02 42,02 31,09 42,86 26,05 36,13 8,40 42,02 25,21 33,61 33,61 33,61 26,05 1226,05 7.3 Per diems 01.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 98 165 19 G.J. COFFEE AKYOL GIDA TURİZM AKYOL GIDA TURİZM 27,50 10,00 14,00 23,11 8,40 11,76 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 03.02.2010 176 179 53076 23629 AKYOL GIDA TURİZM AKYOL GIDA TURİZM FATOŞUN YERİ TEPE OTEL 7.3 Per diems Total 15,00 32,00 1.080,00 3.030,40 4208,90 12,61 26,89 907,56 2546,55 3536,89 7.4 Rental of Facilities 03.02.2010 23628 TEPE OTEL 750,00 630,25 7.4 Rental of Facilities Total 7. COST OF WORKSHOP(S)/ TRAINING COURSE(S) TOTAL 750,00 7162,89 GRAND TOTAL 48328,54 40612,22 * The exchange rate is taken as 1,19 TL following the rate applied in the project application. 630,25 6019,24